Speaking of desserts that are Worth It (my previous post), here is the list of chocolate chip cookies that I have tried in the city (....yes, I have been keeping track) and my favorites.
Top Tier - Very Special Cookies
Birdbath (owned by City Bakery): Everyone likes their cookies a different way. As a chewy girl, to me, these cookies are perfect. The flavors are distinct - vanilla, brown sugar, butter, chocolate. The amount of chocolate does not overpower the delicious said flavors. The cookie is rather large (no opinion on that), flat and chewy with parts of softness and crispness. It is not to be missed. I have seen people walk out of the store empty-handed when told that chocolate chips cookies have run out. (I go to the location on 7th ave at Charles St).
Jacques Torres: Get a warm chocolate chip cookie from here and you will be in heaven. His chocolate is so good; it is highlighted by its presence in flat, square slabs within the cookie. And when its melting...! Cookie itself has great flavor, balanced between ingredients.
Jack's Coffee: This is a cookie for traditionalists. Small compared to what we see in bakery cases these days, but about the size of what you would make at home. They are thick and soft, and of course, meet the mandatory criteria of being deliciously flavored. They are labeled Aunt Rosie's Chocolate Chip Cookies, further emphasizing the nod to traditional cookies. By the way, the cookies are in a cake platter at the register, don't be discouraged when you dont see them in the bakery case :)
Levain Bakery: Take at look at that picture in the link and tell me it doesnt make you want to eat one. These cookies are mammoth in size and in history. I brought a few home to my family (cookie lovers too) and the favorite was the one pictured, a chocolate peanut butter one. The chocolate cookie was so richly flavored, and the size/density was unique, adding to the deliciousness.
Second Tier - Very Good, still Exquisite
Levain Bakery: Take at look at that picture in the link and tell me it doesnt make you want to eat one. These cookies are mammoth in size and in history. I brought a few home to my family (cookie lovers too) and the favorite was the one pictured, a chocolate peanut butter one. The chocolate cookie was so richly flavored, and the size/density was unique, adding to the deliciousness.
Second Tier - Very Good, still Exquisite
Milk & Cookies: Delicous cookies, can be made fresh to order, and offers amazing cookie sandwiches, as I mentioned in the last post. Highly recommended.
Momofuku Milk Bar: Yummy. I gotta go back and try this one: cornflake-marshmallow-chocolate chip. (Their pies are obscenely good.)
Third Tier - Good but I have some complaint.
Bouchon Bakery: Good! Not blown away. Flavors not as strong as I like and a bit dense for my taste. Browned edges yummy.
Insomnia Cookies: Good but a bit greasy for my taste and far too large. A cookie meal. I also really didnt like the bakery itself/location. Felt like a McDonald's for cookies. Love the delivery concept though.
********************************
Any good places I missed? Let me know in the comments, so I can continue my research. Help a sister out. (You can also take the poll on my page!)
Also, let it be known, that while I love chocolate chip cookies and use them as a standard by which to measure a bakery, my favorite cookie to eat and to make is a ginger cookie (any variation of molassas cookie, gingerbread cookie, ginger snap, etc). And in fact, I am happy with a ginger cookie from almost anywhere, I love them that much. :) Some favorites are from Birdbath and Once Upon a Tart.
Third Tier - Good but I have some complaint.
Bouchon Bakery: Good! Not blown away. Flavors not as strong as I like and a bit dense for my taste. Browned edges yummy.
Insomnia Cookies: Good but a bit greasy for my taste and far too large. A cookie meal. I also really didnt like the bakery itself/location. Felt like a McDonald's for cookies. Love the delivery concept though.
********************************
Any good places I missed? Let me know in the comments, so I can continue my research. Help a sister out. (You can also take the poll on my page!)
Also, let it be known, that while I love chocolate chip cookies and use them as a standard by which to measure a bakery, my favorite cookie to eat and to make is a ginger cookie (any variation of molassas cookie, gingerbread cookie, ginger snap, etc). And in fact, I am happy with a ginger cookie from almost anywhere, I love them that much. :) Some favorites are from Birdbath and Once Upon a Tart.